Theoretical paper's referee report

Author: lmik

August undefined, 2024

Webb21 nov. 2024 · So the objective of a good referee report is to very briefly state whether and why the contribution is worthwhile (or not) to be published. Do NOT spend time writing a review or a summary of the article. Quite a lot of referees simply paraphrase the abstract of the papers they are reviewing. WebbThus, a referee report should contain a scientifically based argument that explains the referee’s assessment of the importance of the work and details the consider-ations that …

Frontiers A Conceptual Model of Referee Efficacy

Webb26 dec. 2024 · Writing a Good Referee Report By Enago Academy Dec 26, 2024 4 mins read Listen Peer review is a crucial part of scholarly communication. During this process, authors ideally receive helpful comments on the significance and novelty of their work as well as suggestions on how to improve it. WebbYour task as a referee is to evaluate the paper and submit to the Editor an anonymous formal report accompanied by a cover letter. The Editor will forward the referees’ formal … asians games

Guidelines to Write a Referee Report - Harvard University

http://www.parisschoolofeconomics.com/zhuravskaya-ekaterina/teaching/2011_fall/Report_Outline.pdf WebbReferee Report: Title of the paper Author’s name Date of report 1 Overview This should be a very short paragraph to give the editor an overview of the paper and (if you are a junior … atalenta.be

Institute of Mathematical Statistics Annals of Statistics …

WebbA referee hunch that theoretical or empirical results are wrong is not a scholarly argument against a paper’s conclusions. Instead, as referee you must provide scientifically based reasons whyyou suspect the results are not correct. WebbIf the paper uses panel data but does not present robust and heteroskedasticity-consistent standard errors, you might ask for the revision to do so. If a paper has several parts, for … asians ladyWebb18 feb. 2011 · This paper presents a conceptual model of referee efficacy, defines the concept, proposes sources of referee specific efficacy information, and suggests consequences of having high or low referee efficacy. Referee efficacy is defined as the extent to which referees believe they have the capacity to perform successfully in their job. asians dating

"WebbBelow, we provide a list of concepts and thoughts that referees can consider when writing a referee report. We divide the list into six main categories: sufficiency of contribution, … " - Theoretical paper's referee report

Theoretical paper's referee report

Writing a Good Referee Report - Enago Academy

http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~amaral/courses/605/papers/taskofthereferee.pdf http://users.nber.org/~nikolovp/studentresources/refreport.pdf

Did you know?

Webb26 dec. 2024 · Write your report in an understandable and organized way. Be unnecessarily harsh or unpolite; your criticism should be constructive in tone. Let the editors know if … WebbTheoretical Economics Submitting a paper To submit a paper to Theoretical Economics , The submitting author must be a member of the Econometric Society The submitting author must pay a submission fee with the exceptions noted below. The fee is 100 USD for regular members and 50 USD for student members.

WebbThe referee should show restraint when asking for new material and, indeed, make suggestions for how the paper can be made shorter and more focused. It is important … WebbAcademic papers are usually sent to academic journals for publication. Once she receives a paper, the editor of a journal consults an external scholar (more commonly called “referee”) to see if the paper is suitable for publication. The referee reads the papers and writes a referee report.

Webb17 nov. 2024 · Referee instructions Journal aims and scope Criteria for publication The review process Selecting referees Writing the review Elements of a reviewer report Confidentiality Timing Anonymity... Webbreferee the paper tell the journal. • agree to report but then fail to send it. Instead ask for more time or let the journal know you can no longer report. • contact the authors under …

WebbThe referee report A good referee report should have sev-eral parts. First, you should briefly state your recommendation and the reasons for it. Second, you should summarize the point of the paper in one to five sentences, both for the editor™s use and to ensure that you actually understand the paper. Third, you should evaluate the validity ...

Webb15 sep. 2024 · While the data probably exists, referees in an anonymous review process are entitled to anonymity. I suspect that journals would not release the data out of … asians in ukWebb26 maj 2024 · Step one is to read that paper, and understand it. Then read every paper that cites that paper. Then, maybe talk to some people in your area about the criticism and see what they offer. You're trying to refute a referee who flat out says you're wrong. You absolutely need to do due diligence so you can hold your own. asians gardenWebbHere are a few suggestions for referee report writing. For a longer discussion of some of these issues you may wish to consult two papers: Daniel Hamermesh, “The Young Economist’s Guide to Professional Etiquette,” Journal of Economic Perspectives 6 (1992), 169-179 . William Thompson, “Guidelines on Writing Referee Reports,” mimeo, 1998. asians in atlanta georgia